Your Cart   |   Sign In
Unclaimed Property Focus
Blog Home All Blogs
UNCLAIMED PROPERTY FOCUS is a blog written by and for UPPO members, featuring diverse perspectives and insights from unclaimed property practitioners across the U.S. and Canada. We welcome your submissions to Unclaimed Property Focus. Please contact Tim Dressen via tim@uppo.org with any questions about submitting a blog post for consideration and refer to our editorial guidelines when writing your blog post. Disclaimer: Information and/or comments to this blog is not intended as a substitute for legal advice on compliance or reporting requirements.

 

Search all posts for:   

 

Top tags: unclaimed property  Compliance  education  Delaware  UPPO  litigation  audits  due diligence  fall reporting  Advocacy  UPPO Annual Conference  reporting  Gift Cards  reform  california  legislation  RUUPA  Members  ULC  VDAs  Canada  UP101  spring reporting  UP Laws  fraud  Texas  Uniform Law Commission  voluntary disclosure agreements  Colorado  DEI 

Card Compliant Settles with New York for Nearly $4.4 Million

Posted By UPPO, Thursday, January 9, 2025
Updated: Thursday, January 9, 2025
On Dec. 20, 2024, New York Attorney General Letitia James announced a settlement with gift card company Card Compliant LLC over its role in fashion retailer H&M’s treatment of uncashed gift cards. H&M previously settled with the state in May 2022 for approximately $36 million.

New York requires gift card issuers to turn over unused gift card balances to the state’s Abandoned Property Fund after five years of inactivity.

The state’s Office of the Attorney General opened an investigation into H&M in 2016, after a whistleblower filed a lawsuit under the New York False Claims Act, and found that H&M knew it was required to transfer millions of dollars in unredeemed gift card balances to the Abandoned Property Fund but did not do so.

In order to avoid relinquishing these funds, H&M entered into an agreement with Card Compliant, which was intended to make it look like Card Compliant, not H&M, issued and administered its gift cards, according to the OAG. Card Compliant operates its business out of Leawood, Kansas, and, therefore, was not required to transfer unredeemed balances to New York’s Office of Unclaimed Funds.

In 2011, the New York Comptroller’s Office contacted H&M about the contract between H&M and Card Compliant. Card Compliant allegedly advised H&M to share only some of the contract terms with the Comptroller’s Office and not to disclose the fee provisions that would have revealed that H&M kept the unredeemed gift card balances.

Card Compliant also allegedly prepared a letter for the Comptroller’s Officer falsely claiming that the company had paid out tens of millions of dollars in connection with H&M gift card redemptions. In reality, Card Compliant had not done this and lacked the resources to honor H&M’s millions of dollars of outstanding gift cards, according to the OAG. Card Compliant allegedly made misleading statements to the Comptroller’s Office to falsely imply that Card Compliant, not H&M, performed the gift-card issuance and marketing services and retained the unredeemed gift card balances.

“Today’s agreement resolves allegations that Card Compliant provided false statements to the Comptroller’s office and advised H&M to make false statements to avoid turning over the unused balances on gift cards to the state,” the OAG’s statement said. “As part of the agreement, Card Compliant will pay $4.37 million to New York state, of which more than $1 million will be paid to the whistleblower.”

Unclaimed property professionals interested in gift card compliance – as well as stored-value, payroll, loyalty and prepaid cards – can learn more by attending the Navigating the Rugged Card Landscape session at the 2025 UPPO Annual Conference.

This post has not been tagged.

PermalinkComments (0)
 

December 2024 President's Message

Posted By 2024/25 UPPO President Freda Pepper, Thursday, December 19, 2024
Updated: Tuesday, December 17, 2024
Happy holidays! As we wrap up a productive calendar year for UPPO, we have a lot to look forward to in 2025. We’re only about three months away from the UPPO Annual Conference in Tucson, Arizona, and it’s shaping up to be an incredible week. As part of our world-class lineup of educational sessions and networking events, we’ll celebrate 30 years of UPPO. If you haven’t yet registered, do so by Jan. 17 to take advantage of early-bird rates. I hope to see you there.

Over the past several months and continuing into 2025, a major UPPO initiative is refining our advocacy work. I am pleased to announce the formation of our new Operational Compliance Issues Task Force, which will explore the need for a standing committee focused on practical issues related to unclaimed property compliance and complementing our Government Relations and Advocacy Committee’s (GRAC’s) work.

We continue to enhance our advocacy efforts by relationship-building with the states. Indeed, having a relationship with state administrators built on mutual respect helps ensure our voice is heard when issues of concern arise. To that end, I’d like to report that recently, we engaged in productive conversations with Idaho Treasurer Julie Ellsworth regarding UPPO’s concerns related to recent changes in Idaho’s unclaimed property law. She was overwhelmingly receptive to our concerns, requested further dialogue and draft revisions, and has agreed to seek amendments to help resolve our member’s challenges with some of the confusing and problematic language in the state’s unclaimed property law.

These are just a few initiatives underway as we transition to a new calendar year. Thank you to our committee and task force members, who have been working hard on these and other issues, and thanks to you for your ongoing membership and engagement with UPPO. On behalf of your UPPO Board, I wish you a happy holiday season and a prosperous new year.

This post has not been tagged.

PermalinkComments (0)
 

DEIB Spotlight: Holiday Inclusion

Posted By UPPO, Wednesday, December 18, 2024
Updated: Tuesday, December 17, 2024
With the traditional holiday season upon us, workplace celebrations are plentiful. Ensuring that workplace festivities and recognition are a positive experience for everyone requires awareness and sensitivity to various traditions and differing levels of comfort in participating. When planning future workplace activities, keep these considerations in mind:
  • Go neutral. Focus on togetherness, joy, giving and gratitude rather than a specific holiday.
  • Be aware and flexible. Check online holiday calendars before scheduling meetings and events to ensure they don’t conflict with religious obligations.
  • Be sensitive to specific needs. Are holiday activities accessible to participants regardless of physical limitations? Are food options available for those with restrictions or allergies?
  • Be curious, not defensive. If someone tells you they don’t celebrate the same holiday or prefer not to participate in an activity for cultural reasons, show curiosity about their traditions. Ask whether they are celebrating any winter holidays or have any year-end traditions. They’ll probably appreciate your interest.
  • Make participation optional. Allow people to opt out without guilt. Making activities optional but later making comments suggesting they should have been there can be just as insensitive as making events mandatory.
  • Use what you know. If you know someone celebrates Hanukkah, they’ll probably appreciate being wished a “happy Hanukkah.” If you wish someone “Merry Christmas” and they tell you they don’t celebrate, “Happy Holidays” works as a nonspecific alternative to cover all options.
  • Ask for feedback. After the holidays, take a survey and request feedback about holiday activities. Ask what could be done to make activities more positive and inclusive.
UPPO member Riyaz Dharamshi, founder and CEO of Missingweath, is Muslim, so he doesn’t celebrate Christmas. However, he considers the winter holiday a time to gather with family and friends.

“Because everybody is away from school and work, it’s a great time to take a breath, spend time with family and friends, and plan for the new year,” he said. “It really feels like the only time when most people – except those working as first responders, in hospitals and similar jobs – can slow down, maybe watch some cartoons with the kids and not have to worry about getting to work or school.”

The natural break from work also allows for participation in community activities unrelated to the holidays as well.

“We have a Friday prayer similar to a Sunday Church service,” Dharamshi said. “It’s in the middle of the day, so it’s usually difficult for people in countries that aren’t predominantly Muslim to participate because they’re at work. Over the two weeks at the end of the year, that Friday service is really packed, so we get to reconnect with people in our local community.”

Whether you celebrate Christmas, Hanukkah, Diwali, Kwanzaa, something else, a combination or none of the above, respect goes a long way when navigating various holidays and traditions. Find commonalities, learn about differences and allow everyone to enjoy the winter holidays however they choose.

“This time of year presents an ideal opportunity to bond over food, take stock, be grateful for what we have and reflect with friends and family,” Dharamshi said.
 

End-of-Year Holiday Primer

  • Christmas – Dec. 25, 2024: The Christian celebration of the birth of Jesus.
  • Hannukah – Dec. 25, 2024 – Jan. 2, 2025: The eight-day Jewish celebration recognizing the rededication of the temple in Jerusalem.
  • Kwanzaa – Dec. 26, 2024 – Jan. 1, 2025: The weeklong celebration of African cultural and social values.
  • New Year’s Eve – Dec. 31, 2024: The final day of the calendar year.
  • New Year’s Day – Jan. 1, 2025: The first day of the new calendar year.
     

Tags:  DEIB  inclusion 

PermalinkComments (0)
 

It’s in the Bag Webinar Follow-Up Question

Posted By UPPO, Thursday, December 12, 2024
Updated: Wednesday, December 11, 2024
UPPO’s recent It’s in the Bag webinar defined unique retail properties, discussed key differences when determining whether to report, and examined special state requirements regarding gift cards, promotions and rebates. Because limited time prevented presenters from responding to some of the participant questions during the webinar, they kindly agreed to respond for publication on UPPO’s Unclaimed Property Focus blog. The webinar is available exclusively to members on demand.

I have a VISA gift card issued by Tango Cards. They state a seven-month expiration period. Can they keep the residual funds, or do they have to remit as unclaimed property? I have over $400 left on a card, and they tell me they don't have to give me my funds, even in the form of a “new” card.
This sounds like a promotional card that was issued without direct monetary consideration from the card recipient. These cards do not produce unclaimed property, and they are not “cash” that can be refunded.

Please clarify the difference between a stored-value card and a gift card. In RUUPA, most of the states draw a distinction.
Gift cards are a subset of stored-value cards. Please see Slide 9 of the webinar presentation (available with the webinar recording on UPPO's On-Demand Webinar page) for a more complete discussion of this issue.

Please discuss the difference between the card plastic expiring and the underlying value expiring. The underlying funds represented by most closed-loop gift cards do not expire.
However, because of technological changes and fraud concerns, the plastic that evidences those funds may not be accepted by updated point-of-sale systems or websites. In those situations, the federal CARD Act allows the gift card issuer to issue a new piece of plastic to evidence the funds.

When state law provides differing escheat rules for stored-value cards versus gift cards, what property type codes do holders use to report each?
Not all states have different reporting codes for stored value cards versus gift cards, but where the reporting rules differ, the code for gift cards is MS12 (“MS Twelve”), and the code for stored value cards is MSI2 (MS, the letter “I” and the number 2).

I recently discovered that a restaurant chain’s gift cards cannot be used when there is a small leftover amount, not even through a split transaction with another card. As far as you know, is this legal? Or could you provide commentary on this? It is stated on their website that their gift card program “follows Indiana gift law,” if this helps.
I think that the terms and conditions of the gift card would address this situation. I am guessing that the terms and conditions state that the gift card can be reloaded. If so, you can add value to the card up to the amount of the lowest-priced item on the menu and use the entire balance of the card to purchase that item. It’s a pain in the neck and not good practice, but there is nothing strictly illegal about it as long as the value can be added to the card and the terms and conditions address the issue.

Some states have called out “Financial Institution Loyalty Cards” as specifically exempt. How do these differ from other loyalty cards?
There are several distinctions between a standard loyalty card and a financial institution loyalty card (FILC). First, the FILC must be issued through a promotional program established by a financial organization, including savings and loan associations, banks and credit unions, whereas a standard loyalty card can be issued by any retailer or service provider. Also, while there are usually restrictions on loyalty cards requiring that they be issued without any direct monetary consideration, FILC programs can have carveouts for monetary consideration or annual or periodic fees. Finally, loyalty programs typically have restrictions that they may be used or redeemed only to obtain goods, services or discounts but cannot be redeemed for money, whereas FILCs can be redeemable for money or monetized by the financial organization issuing the FLIC.

It is a rewards card for 30 years of service, and I would love to have any help working through this situation and getting the funds back if possible.
See my response to the first question above. I do not think a card recipient can get “funds” back from the issuer. However, you could sell the card on an auction site if you do not want to use the card to buy goods and services.

I thought gift cards were single-load instruments while the stored-value cards were general-purpose reloadable instruments.
Many closed-loop gift cards are, in fact, reloadable. However, because of fraud concerns, issuers of closed-loop gift cards are starting to turn off the reloadability function.

Tags:  gift cards  rebates  stored-value cards 

PermalinkComments (0)
 

Unclaimed Property News Roundup

Posted By UPPO, Friday, December 6, 2024
Updated: Friday, December 6, 2024
Unclaimed property often makes news headlines, and UPPO occasionally provides a snapshot of some of the more interesting and entertaining stories receiving coverage from local and national media outlets in recent weeks.

On Nov. 14, 2024, KRCA 3 News reported about a mailroom employee in the California State Controller’s Office who was convicted of stealing the contents of safe deposit boxes that had been escheated to the state as unclaimed property.

The Fayette Tribute reported on Nov. 22, 2024, that approximately 40% of unclaimed property checks totaling $1.1 million that were sent to West Virginia residents in September remained uncashed.

In late November, gambling news sites Poker.org and Yogonet reported on new proposed legislation in New Jersey for handling dormant funds in inactive online gambling accounts. This property type has been a growing area of interest for lawmakers since the expansion of online sports gambling beyond Nevada began in 2018.

This post has not been tagged.

PermalinkComments (0)
 
Page 1 of 114
1  |  2  |  3  |  4  |  5  |  6  >   >>   >| 
Membership Software Powered by YourMembership  ::  Legal